
Plate cutting is one of those decisions that gets made for you by the fabricator, and most of the time that is fine. It is worth understanding anyway, because it affects edge quality, cost and what you can reasonably ask for.
Oxy-fuel flame cutting burns through the steel with a preheated oxygen jet. It handles genuinely thick carbon steel economically, well beyond what plasma or laser reach, and the equipment is robust and widely available. The kerf is wider and the heat-affected zone larger, so it suits structural work where a few tenths of a millimetre do not matter, rather than precision components. It does not work on stainless or aluminium.
Plasma cutting pushes an ionised gas jet through the metal and cuts far faster than flame on mid-range thicknesses. It handles stainless and aluminium, which flame cannot, and leaves a narrower kerf. Edge squareness is good but not perfect, and there is usually a small amount of dross to dress off.
Laser cutting gives the cleanest, squarest edge and the tightest tolerances, often good enough to weld or assemble straight off the machine with no secondary work. It is limited to thinner material than the other two, and the machine time costs more per metre.
The practical question is not which process is best but what happens to the edge next. An edge that gets welded into an assembly does not need to be beautiful. An edge that remains visible, or that mates precisely against another part, does, and paying for the better process up front is usually cheaper than grinding afterwards.
If you are unsure, send the drawing and say what the part has to do. A fabricator with more than one process available will pick the one that gets you the result for the least money, which is not always the fanciest machine on the floor.